Why men get angry instead of sad

Anger is often the only emotion many men were given permission to express, so other feelings arrive wearing it. Irritability, a short fuse and reactions out of proportion to the trigger are common ways that low mood, exhaustion, grief and fear present in men. The anger is usually accurate about something. It’s rarely accurate about what’s in front of you.

A few years ago I asked myself a question for the first time.

“What am I feeling?”

I don’t think the question itself was new. What was new was answering it honestly.

The answer was frustration. Not at one thing. At a stack of things that had been quietly compounding for weeks. An injury that wasn’t healing on any timeline I found acceptable. The state of mind the injury had put me in. The constant need to stay the course while feeling like I was going nowhere.

Sad. Frustrated. Disappointed. Angry. Restless.

All of it at once, and every bit of it coming out the same way.

Because for a lot of men, anger is the only emotion that was ever sanctioned.

Think about what happens when a man is visibly sad in front of other people. Questions. Concern. Discomfort. Someone asking if he is alright, which is the last thing he wants.

Now think about what happens when he is angry. People give him room.

One of those responses is much easier to live with if what you want is to be left alone with it. So over years and decades, other feelings learn to travel under a passport that gets through the checkpoint.

Fear comes out as anger. Grief comes out as anger. Exhaustion comes out as anger. Shame, which is the one almost nobody names, comes out as anger with the volume turned up.

Then the man on the receiving end of it, usually a partner or a kid, gets the whole thing, and he can’t explain it either, because from the inside it feels like it’s about the dishwasher.

It can be, and this is worth taking seriously without leaping to conclusions.

Persistent irritability, a fuse that’s shorter than it used to be, and reactions that are out of proportion to what triggered them are commonly recognised as ways that low mood presents in men. Not the only way, and not a diagnosis. But a pattern that turns up often enough to be worth paying attention to.

The reason it matters is that the standard picture of depression is a man sitting quietly in a dark room. So a man who’s snapping at everyone and working sixty hours a week doesn’t see himself in it, and neither does anyone around him. He gets described as difficult rather than struggling, which closes the door on the conversation that might have helped.

If any of this is landing, the next step isn’t to self-diagnose from a blog post. It’s a conversation with a GP, who can actually assess what’s going on properly.

In my experience, on myself and in the work, it’s almost always one of three things.

Loss. Something has gone and hasn’t been mourned, because there was no obvious place to mourn it. A relationship, a role, a body that used to work properly, an idea of how life was going to look.

Fear. Something is coming, or might be, and there’s no way to control it. Anger at least feels like doing something, where fear feels like standing still.

Exhaustion. Sometimes it’s not psychological at all. Sometimes a man has been running on five hours of broken sleep for eight months and has no capacity left for anything, and every small demand hits an empty tank.

Those are worth separating, because they need different things.

Start with the question, and be prepared for it to be harder than it sounds.

What am I feeling?

Most men’s first honest attempt produces something like “annoyed” or “over it,” and that’s a fine start. Sit with it a bit longer and something more specific usually turns up underneath.

Then, and this is the bit that does the work, notice the gap between the size of the trigger and the size of the reaction. If a small thing produced a large response, the response wasn’t about the small thing. It was about whatever was already loaded and waiting for somewhere to go.

That gap is the most useful piece of information you’ve. It tells you the anger is accurate about something. It just isn’t accurate about the person in front of you.

None of this means you shouldn’t be angry. Anger is a legitimate response to plenty of things, and some of them deserve it. Injustice deserves it. Being treated badly deserves it.

But feeling all of it, naming it, and sitting in it long enough to work out what it’s, that’s how it moves. The ideas become words. The words become a conversation. And over time, acceptance joins the conversation.

Nothing changes if nothing changes.

• Ask the question daily for a week. What am I feeling. Once a day, out loud or on paper. The first few attempts will be poor. That’s normal.

• Measure the gap. Next time you react, ask how big the trigger was compared to the reaction. The size of the gap tells you how much was already loaded.

• Check the physical basics first. Sleep, food, alcohol, movement. A surprising amount of what presents as anger is a body running on empty.

• Tell one person the real version. Not “I’m fine, just tired.” The actual version. It doesn’t have to be a professional. It can be anyone you trust.

• Get it out of your head and onto paper. Ten minutes, no editing, no reader. Half of what terrorises you in your head looks flimsy in ink.

This week: once a day, ask yourself what you’re actually feeling and answer honestly. Write the answer down. One word is enough.

Anger is frequently the emotion other feelings travel under, particularly for men who learned early that anger was the acceptable one. Loss, fear and exhaustion commonly present this way. Persistent anger is usually accurate about something, but rarely about the thing that triggered it.

Irritability and a short fuse are commonly recognised as ways low mood can present in men, though anger alone isn’t a diagnosis of anything. If it has been persistent and is affecting your relationships or work, a GP is the right person to assess it properly.

Because they’re usually the only people you’re not performing for. The version of you that holds it together all day at work has nothing left by the time you get home, and home is the one place the mask comes off.

Start by checking the physical basics, since sleep debt, alcohol and no movement account for a large share of it. Then work on naming what’s underneath, because anger that has been identified behaves very differently to anger that hasn’t.

Structured anger programmes suit some people well. For many men the more useful work is on what the anger is carrying rather than on techniques for containing it, since containment alone tends to postpone rather than resolve. A GP or counsellor can help you work out which fits.

Solid Foundations Counselling is not a crisis service. If you need support right now, Lifeline is available 24 hours on 13 11 14, and 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 for family and domestic violence. In an emergency, call 000.

If the anger has been running the show for a while and you want to work out what’s underneath it, I offer a free introductory call. No cost, no pressure, no obligation. Click the banner above or get in touch on 0422967392.

• What anxiety actually feels like
• The darkness: what depression actually looks like