Category:
Reading Time:
5 minute read

Overthinking Feels Like a Mental Tug-of-War

You replay conversations in your head, second-guess decisions, and get stuck in endless “what if” scenarios. Overthinking can make even simple choices feel overwhelming.

It feels productive – like you’re preparing for every possible outcome – but in reality, it just keeps you stuck.

So, how do you break free?

Counselling can help you identify what fuels your overthinking, challenge unhelpful thought patterns, and create mental clarity so you can move forward with confidence.

Why Do We Overthink?

Overthinking often comes from fear, anxiety, or the desire to be “perfect.” You might worry about:

🔹 Making the wrong decision

🔹 How others perceive you

🔹 Things outside of your control

🔹 The future and all the “what ifs”

The problem? Thinking more doesn’t always lead to better outcomes. It can actually make decision-making harder.

Signs Overthinking Is Holding You Back

Do any of these sound familiar?

🚩 You analyze past conversations and wonder if you said the “wrong” thing

🚩 You struggle to make decisions, even about small things

🚩 You play out worst-case scenarios in your mind

🚩 You feel mentally exhausted from constant worrying

🚩 You seek reassurance from others but still feel unsure

Overthinking often disguises itself as problem-solving, but instead of finding answers, you just feel stuck.

How Counselling Helps Break the Cycle of Overthinking

Therapy gives you tools to manage your thoughts instead of letting them control you. Here’s how:

1️⃣ Identifying Thought Patterns That Keep You Stuck

Many people who overthink don’t realize they’re doing it – it feels like normal thinking.

A counsellor helps you recognize when you’re overanalyzing and guides you toward healthier ways of processing decisions.

2️⃣ Challenging “What If” Thinking

Overthinking thrives on uncertainty:

❓ “What if I fail?”

❓ “What if I regret this decision?”

❓ “What if people judge me?”

Counselling helps you reframe these thoughts by asking:

✔️ What’s the evidence this will actually happen?

✔️ If the worst-case scenario did happen, how would I handle it?

✔️ What’s a more realistic way to look at this?

This shift stops fear from running the show.

3️⃣ Learning to Trust Yourself

Overthinking often stems from self-doubt – you don’t trust your ability to handle uncertainty.

Therapy helps you:

✅ Build confidence in your choices

✅ Accept that no decision is perfect – but that’s okay

✅ Stop relying on outside reassurance and start trusting yourself

The goal isn’t to never overthink – it’s to know when to let a thought go and move forward.

4️⃣ Practicing Mindfulness & Mental Clarity

Overthinking pulls you into the past (“Did I say the wrong thing?”) or the future (“What if this goes wrong?”).

Mindfulness techniques help you stay in the present moment, where anxiety has less control.

Try this:

🌿 5-4-3-2-1 grounding technique

🌿 Deep breathing to slow racing thoughts

🌿 Journaling to get thoughts out of your head and onto paper

Small Changes Lead to Big Results

The first step to overcoming overthinking is recognizing that you don’t have to do it alone.

Counselling gives you the support, tools, and mindset shifts needed to move from overthinking to clear, confident decision-making.

Ready to break free from overthinking? Book a free 15-min consultation here. You don’t have to stay stuck. Change starts now.

About the author

Sean Menere | Dip. Couns.

As a registered counsellor, Sean draws on his professional and lived experience when navigating both common and not-so-common life challenges. He uses this approach to help others rebuild their own foundations and navigate successfully towards meaningful progress.

Successful navigation requires knowing your starting point.

Use our interactive Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale tool (DASS21) to help establish your starting point before taking your next step.